| |
Appearance |
Protection |
Durability |
Safety |
Ease of Application |
Reversibility |
Rubbing Qualities |
| Wax |
Creates shine |
Great |
Lasts forever |
Safe when solvents in paste wax evaporate |
Applied with steel wool, needs sanding |
Can easily be removed with solvents |
Needs to be buffed |
| Shellac |
Some yellow or orange tint, depending on grade used |
Fair against water, good on solvents except alcohol |
Durable |
Safe when solvent evaporates, used as food and pill coating |
French polishing difficult technique to master. |
Completely reversible using alcohol |
Excellent |
| Nitrocellulose lacquer |
Transparent, good gloss |
Good protection |
Hard and durable |
Uses toxic solvents, including toluene. Breathing protection is needed, especially if sprayed |
Requires spray equipment. Brush-on products also available |
Completely reversible using lacquer thinner |
Excellent hard finish |
| Conversion lacquer |
Transparent, good gloss |
Excellent protection against many substances |
Hard and durable |
Uses toxic solvents, including toluene. Breathing protection is needed, especially if sprayed |
Requires spray equipment. Used in professional shops |
Difficult to reverse |
Excellent hard finish |
| Linseed oil |
Yellow warm glow, pops grain, darkens with age |
Very little |
Fairly durable, depending on number of coats |
Relatively safe, metallic driers are poisonous |
Easy, apply with rags and wipe off. Takes relatively long time to dry |
Needs sanding out as oil is absorbed |
None |
| Tung oil |
Warm glow, pops grain, lighter than linseed |
Very little |
Fairly durable, depending on number of coats |
Relatively safe, metallic driers are poisonous |
Easy, apply with rags and wipe off. Faster to dry than linseed oil |
Needs sanding out as oil is absorbed |
None |
| Alkyd varnish |
Not as transparent as lacquer, yellowish/orange tint |
Good protection |
Durable |
Relatively safe, uses petroleum based solvents |
Brush or spray. Brushing needs good technique to avoid bubbles & streaks |
Can be stripped using paint removers |
Fair |
| Polyurethane varnish |
Transparent, many coats can look like plastic |
Excellent protection against many substances, tough finish |
Durable |
Relatively safe, uses petroleum based solvents |
Brushing needs good technique to avoid bubbles & streaks |
Can be stripped with difficulty using paint removers |
Bad, coats do not meld leading to white rings if rubbing out cuts through coat |
| Water-based polyurethane |
Transparent, may give cold bluish tinge to wood |
Good protection |
Durable |
Safer than oil-based, fewer volatile organic compounds (VOCs) |
Brush or spray. Brushing needs good technique to avoid bubbles & streaks |
Can be stripped with difficulty using paint removers |
Bad, coats do not meld leading to white rings if rubbing out cuts through coat |
| Oil-varnish mixes |
Similar to oils unless many coats applied, then takes on characteristics of varnishes |
Low, but more than pure oil finishes |
Fairly durable, depending on number of coats |
Relatively safe, uses petroleum based solvents |
Easy, apply with rags and wipe off. Faster to dry than linseed oil |
Needs sanding out as oil is absorbed |
None unless many coats applied |